by joerocker » 14 Oct 2007, 19:14
The switch is fine and dandy...I have one on my RP too. That doesn't mean it's a "magical" switch that takes the unique tone out of EVERY guitar amp.
My point is this: ALL guitar amps have their own "sound", whatever you send through it will pick up this "sound" and it won't be the same as if you were going straight to PA.
Think of it this way...two people are singing the same song. One is a man and the other is a woman, no matter what each does, you can still hear that it's the man or the woman singing. Same with amps, each amp is "its own sound", just like a man sounds like a man and a woman sounds like a woman. So, when you set your tonelab to sound like a "woman", and you're playing it through a "man" amp, it doesn't sound good. When you set it to sound like a "man", the amp adds more "manliness" to it and it STILL doesn't sound good. Do you understand my analogy here?
In amp speak it would be this... The amp is a Peavey, your tonelab is trying to sound like a Marshall, Marshall + Peavey doesn't sound right. Even if your tonelab is set to sound like a Peavey, adding MORE Peavey may not be a good thing.
This is why I'm selling my Vox AD30, no matter what amp model I use, it colors my RP output...and I don't like that...